| 1952 TOPPS #67 ALLIE REYNOLDS YANKEES PSA 4 VGEX | $20.61 |
| 1952 TOPPS #67 ALLIE REYNOLDS YANKEES BLACK BACK | $19.07 |
| 1952 Topps Allie Reynolds Card #67 - YANKEES | $26.10 |
| 2008 UD Yankee Stadium Legacy Allie Reynolds (5) | $0.99 |
| 1953 Bowman Color #68 Allie Reynolds Baseball Card | $7.89 |
| 1955 BOWMAN ALLIE REYNOLDS | $4.95 |
| Allie Reynolds Yankees Signed 1988 Pacific Legends | $1.36 |
| 1949 BOWMAN #114 ALLIE REYNOLDS YANKEES | $8.50 |
| 1955 BOWMAN BASEBALL CARD #201 ALLIE REYNOLDS PSA 6 | $7.50 |
| 1951 BOWMAN #109 ALLIE REYNOLDS EX | $16.83 |
| 1951 BOWMAN ALLIE REYNOLDS #109 EX+ TO EXMT | $8.25 |
| Allie Reynolds 1951 51 Bowman #109 - Yankees | $14.31 |
| Allie Reynolds authentic yankee stadium seat | $10.53 |
| 1949 BOWMAN #114 ALLIE REYNOLDS YANKEES VG NICE | $9.58 |
| 1955 Bowman #201 - ALLIE REYNOLDS - Yankees - PSA 5 | $9.05 |
| 1951 TOPPS RED BACK ALLIE REYNOLDS BASEBALL CARD FOUND | $4.77 |
| 1955 Bowman #201 ALLIE REYNOLDS pitcher Ney York Yankee | $0.99 |
| 2007 SP Legendary Cuts Allie Reynolds NY Yankees NM+ | $0.29 |
| 1955 Baseball MLB Armour coin Allie P. Reynolds BIN | $9.19 |
| 2008 Yankee Stadium Legacy Allie Reynolds YSL-1888 | $0.99 |
| 1951 Bowman #109 Allie Reynolds Baseball Card | $12.50 |